We can trace the origin of readability formulas during the late 19th Century in the United States. The schools in the US did not routinely grade students until 1847 when the first graded school opened in Boston with a series of books prepared for each grade. Junior high school science teachers wanted to teach scientific facts and methods in plain English, rather than teaching complicated science vocabulary. As a result, teachers, librarians, and scholars developed primitive readability formulas to determine what seemed readable to their students.
No one had ever entertained the thought of grading adults. The US Military took the first step in grading adults in 1917. Chicago took the clue from the military and started grading civilians in 1937. Earlier studies had revealed that general adult readers in the United States had limited reading ability.
The breakthrough of readability formulas was the publication of The Teachers Word Book
by Edward Thorndike
in 1921. In his book, Thorndike tabulated the frequency of difficult words used in general literature. For the first time, a notable scholar
suggested a means to measure difficult words through mathematical formulas.
Early researchers tabulated surface characteristics of written texts to determine the extent readers could comprehend texts. Then they compared the data with certain predetermined standards; one such standard was tabulating the average grade level of students who could correctly answer a certain percentage of questions from the text. The characteristics with the most accurate standards were judged as indices of readability. These characteristics were worked upon and developed into readability formulas.
Thorndikes book was followed by another landmark work by George Kingsley Zipf
in 1949. Zipf came up with Human Behavior and The Principle of Least Effort
, in which he declared a mathematical relationship between the hard and easy words, called Zipfs Curve
Many researchers have contributed to developing readability formulas. Rudolf Flesch
is one of the better known developers of a readability formula called Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level
. His formula uses the number of syllables per 100 words and the average number of words per sentence.
Flesch said that writers can make their texts easier to read by using shorter words and shorter sentences.
In 1963 George R. Klare
published his book, The Measurement of Readability
, in which he reviewed the efforts to improve comprehensible language by revising the texts to lower readability scores. He also suggested using readability formulas as an aid to increase effectiveness of writing and speaking. Klare published over 80 papers and studies on readability in professional and scholarly journals. He died in 2006.
Some of the other significant contributors
of readability formulas include Edgar Dale
, Jeanne Chall
, Robert Gunning
, Ed Fry
, Tom Trabasso
, and J. Peter Kinkaid
Presently, there are over 200 readability formulas with varying degrees of accuracy and success rate. There is much debate about which readability formula is foolproof. All formulas have some significance in improving the readability of text. ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Brian Scott is a contributing writer for Lousy Writer where he helps writers and non-writers how to write better.